Courts May Deny Mentally Ill the Right to Represent Themselves

Contact a Criminal Lawyer

June 19th, 2008

"Indiana Supreme Court Overturns Ruling"

In a 7-2 ruling, the Supreme Court decided that it does not violate the Constitution to deny mentally ill criminal defendants the right to represent themselves in cases where they’ve been deemed fit to stand trial.

The Case at Issue

At issue was the case of Ahmad Edwards, a mentally ill criminal defendant who was convicted of murder in 2005. Edwards, who is both delusional and schizophrenic, wanted to represent himself when he was judged competent to be tried. The court denied his request and he was convicted.

Edwards appealed his case in Indiana courts, arguing that his right to represent himself in criminal proceedings had been violated. The courts agreed, Edwards’ conviction was overturned, and a new trial was ordered.

Majority Ruling

The Supreme Court set aside the Indiana ruling on Thursday, stating in the majority opinion that it is in the government’s best interest to ensure fair criminal trials, and that this may mean denying a defendant’s request to self-representation.

(Source: Reuters)

Facing criminal charges? It’s in your best interest to ensure your rights are protected. Contact an experienced criminal defense attorney near you today.